Ex Parte Rupich et al - Page 10


                Appeal 2007-2236                                                                                   
                Application 10/991,738                                                                             
            1          Mizuta describes a method of preparing a superconductive material.                          
            2   Page 2:3.                                                                                          
            3          Like Rupich's article, the Mizuta superconductor has a layer                                
            4   corresponding to Rupich's layer 14.                                                                
            5          The Mizuta layer comprises an oxide which can have the empirical                            
            6   formula AB2Cu3O7+x, where x is a number greater than -1 but less that +1.                          
            7   When the x is about -1, the empirical formula of Mizuta is close to that of                        
            8   Rupich.  Mizuta, page 3:40                                                                         
            9          "A" can be Y, La, Nd, Sm, Eu, Gd, Dy, Ho, Er, Yb, Lu or a mixture of                        
          10    two more thereof.  Mizuta, 3:43.  These elements are rare earth metals.                            
          11           "B" can be Ba, Sr, Ca or a mixture of two ore more thereof.                                 
          12    Mizuta 3:44.  These elements are alkaline earth metals.                                            
          13           What surfaces from the description in Mizuta is that the Mizuta layer                       
          14    comprises the same oxide, albeit made by a different process.  We do not                           
          15    know the critical current density of the Mizuta layers corresponding layer 14                      
          16    of Rupich.                                                                                         
          17           The Mizuta examples tell us a little about the properties made from                         
          18    different rare earth metals.                                                                       
          19           Examples 1 and 2 describe films made from lanthanum (La) salts and                          
          20    not yttrium (Y) salts.  Critical temperatures are reported as (on set) of 30 K                     
          21    and 27K and perfect superconductivity is reported as 10 K and 10 K.                                
          22           Examples 3 through 17 describe films made from yttrium instead of                           
          23    lanthanum.  Critical temperatures are reported as (on set) ranging from a                          
          24    high of 97 to a low of 30 and perfect superconductivity is reported from a                         
          25    high 89 K to a low of 15 K:                                                                        


                                                        10                                                         

Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013