Ex parte SEARS - Page 6




              Appeal No. 94-4461                                                                                           
              Application 07/996,797                                                                                       


              under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b) since it issued more than one year prior to the filing date of this                 
              application, December 24, 1992.                                                                              
                     Upon return of the application, the examiner should determine the effective filing                    
              date of each claim pending in this application.  If any claim pending in the application is not              
              entitled to the benefit of the earlier filing date of parent application 07/771,402, the                     
              examiner should determine whether that claim is patentable over the prior art, including the                 
              `622 patent.                                                                                                 
              3.  Proper search                                                                                            
                     As seen from the claims on appeal, the subject matter under review pertains to                        
              solid foodstuffs.  From the “SEARCHED” section of the administrative file, it does not                       
              appear that the examiner has searched class 426 which is directed to foodstuffs. As set                      
              forth above, one embodiment of the present invention would be to administer a solid                          
              foodstuff which comprises only protein and carbohydrates in a specified ratio in                             
              conjunction with a separate formulation containing the required fatty acids.                                 
                     As a second matter, it does not appear from the “SEARCH NOTES” portion of the                         
              administrative file jacket that the examiner has searched the available electronic data                      
              bases.  Given the technical subject matter under review in this application, the examiner                    
              should consider whether a complete search should include accessing the electronic data                       
              bases.                                                                                                       


                                                            6                                                              





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007