Ex parte BOUFFARD et al. - Page 20




          Appeal No. 95-0976                                                          
          Application No. 07/936,558                                                  


          as lacking patentable distinction over (1) Claims 1-11 and 13               
          or (2) Claims 1-4 or (3) Claims 3-20 or (4) Claims 4-7 or (5)               
          Claims 1-13 or (6) Claims 1-10 or (7) Claims 1-9 of copending               
          applications (1) 07/936,561; (2) 07/963,332; (3) 07/775,774;                
          (4) 07/960,983; (5) 08/005,942; (6) 07/936,434; and (7)                     
          07/959,948; respectively.                                                   
               With respect to application Serial Number 07/960,983 this              
          rejection is now moot in that this application has been                     
          abandoned.  With respect to application Serial Number                       
          07/775,774 and application Serial Number 07/936,434 this                    
          rejection is no longer provisional in that these applications               
          have issued as U.S. Patent # 5,430,018 and U.S. Patent #                    
          5,348,940, respectively.                                                    
               The Appeal Brief acknowledges this rejection in the                    
          paragraph bridging pages 6 and 7, however no argument is                    
          presented with respect to the merits of this rejection.  In                 
          that no arguments have been presented by appellants as to why               
          the examiner's rejection is erroneous, we summarily affirm                  
          this rejection.                                                             
               In the Appeal Brief on page 7, Appellants "request that                
          the Examiner hold any rejection on these grounds in abeyance                
                                          20                                          





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007