Ex parte ALPERT et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-4010                                                          
          Application 08/082,338                                                      



          a "test operation instruction means" which corresponds to the               
          Appellants' TSTOP                                                           
          instruction 108 disclosed in Appellants' specification and an               
          "instruction execute means" which corresponds to the                        
          Appellants'                                                                 


          instruction execution unit 110 disclosed in Appellants'                     
          specification.  Appellants further state that claim 14 recites              
          a "corresponding potentially undefined target instruction"                  
          which corresponds to instruction INST3 disclosed in                         
          Appellants' specification.  Appellants' argue that these                    
          limitations are not taught by any combination of the applied                
          references.   In the reply brief and the second reply brief,                
          Appellants emphasized that the Examiner fails to identify                   
          where in the prior art these limitations are taught.                        
                    The Examiner argues in the answer that Zolnowsky                  
          teaches the disclosed invention as substantially claimed.  The              
          Examiner takes claim 14 as an exemplary claim and argues that               
          Zolnowsky teaches an instruction testing means in Figures 1-4;              
          column 2, lines 54-64; column 3, lines 50-63; and columns 5, 6              

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007