Ex parte SIMPSON - Page 2




          Appeal No. 96-2535                                                          
          Application 08/028,473                                                      


          layer having reduced wear resistance characteristics.  The                  
          independent claims on appeal, claim 1 and 14, are reproduced                
          below to further illustrate the claimed subject matter.                     
               1.  A mechanical member adapted to have at least a                     
          portion of its surface slidingly engaged as a wear surface by               
          a mating surface, said member comprising:                                   
               a body having a wear surface, and                                      
               a coating of polycrystalline diamond film on the wear                  
          surface, the coating having a first, outer thickness region of              
          a first material remote from the underlying body and a second,              
          inner thickness region of a second material under the first                 
          thickness region, the second material having a morphology                   
          different from that of the first material.                                  

               14.  A seal assembly for a rotating shaft, comprising:                 
               first and second seal members having mating surfaces for               
          mutually sliding engagement;                                                
               at least the first member mating surface having a                      
          polycrystalline diamond film coating, the coating having a                  
          surface with a reduced wear resistance.                                     

               The references of record relied upon by the examiner as                
          evidence of anticipation and obviousness are:                               
          Linda Plano, Ian Hayward and John Wegand, “CVD Diamond Films                
          For Tribological Applications”, Crystalline Final Report                    
          Contract No.                                                                
          N00014-89-C-0151 (March 30, 1990).                                          



                                          2                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007