Ex parte NAKATANI et al. - Page 6




           Appeal No. 1997-3662                                                                  
           Application No. 07/964,342                                                            


           the Examiner asserts (Answer, pages 2 and 3) the obviousness                          
           to the skilled artisan of modifying Preuss to produce colors                          
           other than black and white.                                                           
                 In response, Appellants’ arguments (Brief, pages 12 and                         
           13) center on the contention that the Examiner has failed to                          
           establish a prima facie case of obviousness since all of the                          
           claimed limitations are not taught or suggested in Preuss.  In                        
           particular, Appellants assert the lack of disclosure in                               
           Preuss, which discusses only black and white images, of the                           
           representation of color image data by combining specific                              
           codewords which are themselves indicative of black and white                          
           run-lengths.                                                                          
















                                               6                                                 





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007