Ex Parte HARTMANN et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 2000-1250                                                            
          Application No. 08/662,077                                     Page 8           

               From the disclosure of Ramstrom, we find that Ramstrom is                  
          directed to adding functionality to the system, and is not                      
          directed to controlling a plurality of switches, each of which                  
          responds to a different set of native messages.  Nor is Ramstrom                
          directed to providing a generic message interpreter to interpret                
          generic messages to control switches which respond to native                    
          switch messages.                                                                
               Astmann is directed to a distributed processing message                    
          delivery system for controlling the distribution of variable                    
          length messages within a telephone system (col. 1, lines 6-15).                 
          To improve the ability of the central processor to pass messages                
          to various remote processors, the information from the main                     
          processor, in accordance with predefined functions, is sent as an               
          entire group of submessages within a single message packet (col.                
          1, lines 6-9, 21-24, 52-62).  In addition, the message can                      
          consist of any number of sub-messages, provided that all of the                 
          messages are destined for the same port processor and they are                  
          all of a general type (col. 3, lines 18-20, and figure 2).                      
          From the disclosure of Astmann, we find that Astmann is directed                
          to providing improved communications between processors in a PBX                
          system.  We find no disclosure of controlling a plurality of                    
          switches, each of which responds to a different set of native                   






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007