Ex Parte SHORTRIDGE et al - Page 4


                 Appeal No.  2004-0329                                                       Page 4                   
                 Application No.  09/251,953                                                                          

                        modified and genetically engineered seeds and grains are                                      
                        becoming common place within the agriculture industry.  The                                   
                        prevalence of these genetically altered products has given rise to a                          
                        market for non-genetically modified seeds, grains, and processed                              
                        products created therefrom.                                                                   
                               It can also be seen that there is a need for a method to                               
                        ensure that the non-genetically modified seeds, grains, and                                   
                        processed products are not contaminated during the process of                                 
                        bringing these products to market.  The method of creating non-                               
                        genetically modified seeds, grains, and processed grain products                              
                        begins prior to the planting of a crop and continues throughout the                           
                        cultivation and harvest of a crop.  Once harvested, the non-                                  
                        genetically modified crop’s processing, packaging, and distribution                           
                        must continue taking steps necessary to prevent contamination of                              
                        the seeds and grains.                                                                         
                 Id. at 1.                                                                                            
                        In order to verify that the crop produced is free of genetically modified                     
                 organisms [GMO], that is, GMO free, the specification teaches:                                       
                               The verification step may also includes [sic] additional                               
                        laboratory testing of the selected seed stock is performed [sic] to                           
                        verify the seed stock is GMO free.  These tests include an                                    
                        application susceptibility or detection test and a DNA level test.                            
                        Satisfactory results from these tests would be influenced by                                  
                        labeling and testing protocols.  For example, a two-tiered approach                           
                        is one possible approach which may be used.  For seeds, grains,                               
                        and processed products which are labeled using language such as                               
                        “ . . . may contain GMO products,” the DNA level test results in the                          
                        1-5% range may be acceptable.  For seeds, grains, and processed                               
                        products labeled as “free of GMO products,”  a more stringent                                 
                        standard of 0.01-0.1% results may be required.  These more                                    
                        stringent standards may present a technical challenge to testing                              
                        accuracy of DNA testing laboratories.                                                         
                 Id. at 6.                                                                                            












Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007