Ex Parte SHIGEMATSU et al - Page 7




               Appeal No. 2004-1026                                                                      Page 7                  
               Application No. 09/028,480                                                                                        


                      Here, Tannenbaum discloses a "method of operating a computer with an                                       
               integrated operating environment and operating system capable of running a plurality of                           
               application programs simultaneously. . . ."  Col. 4, ll. 36-39.  As shown in Figure 9 of the                      
               reference, "[a] graphical user interface 300 is presented on the system display equipped                          
               with a touch sensor over its viewing surface.  Three overlapping                                                  
               windows 302, 304, 306 are displayed which are owned by applications I, J and K                                    
               respectively."  Col. 18, ll. 25-29.                                                                               
                      The reference's "method . . . includes the step of determining which one of the                            
               application programs owns a first window in which a key feature of a gesture was made                             
               by a pointing device."  Col. 4, ll. 44-48.  Specifically, Tannenbaum "designat[es] one key                        
               point within a gesture as a 'hot spot'”.  The window or icon in which the hot spot occurs                         
               is determined to be the focus of the user. . . ."  Col. 18, ll. 45-47.  "Thus, the user is not                    
               restricted to drawing the gesture completely within the window of the target application."                        
               Id. at ll. 58-59.                                                                                                 
                      The reference's "first gesture is a pigtail," id. at l. 68, which it shows in Figure 10.                   
               "Typically, the hot spot is designated to be at a prominent and intuitive point within the                        
               gesture."  Id. at ll. 64-65.  As shown in Figure 10, the pigtail's "hot spot [is] at one end of                   
               the shape," col. 19, l. 1, i.e., either the pen-down end or the pen-up end of the shape.                          
               When the hot spot is at the pen-down end of the pigtail gesture, we find that                                     
               Tannenbaum detects where its pointing device is put down on its display.                                          








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007