Ex Parte Aleles et al - Page 13



             Appeal No. 2006-2248                                                                               
             Application No. 10/158,618                                                                         

                          41. Applicants presented original patent claim 1 along with new                       
             reissue application claims 2-19 for consideration.                                                 
                          42. Reissue application claims 1-19 are before the Board in the                       
             appeal.                                                                                            
                          43. A copy of reissue application claims 1-19 appears in Appendix                     
             5 of this opinion.  Claims 1, 2, 8, and 9 are independent claims.                                  
                          44. In response to the Examiner’s first action on the merits in the                   
             reissue application, Applicants amended the claims to place claims 1-19 in the                     
             proper reissue format and to add new reissue application claims 20-40.                             
                          45. The Examiner withdrew reissue application claims 20-40 from                       
             consideration as being directed to non-elected subject matter (Reissue application                 
             final rejection at page 2).                                                                        
                          46. Reissue application claims 20-40 are not before the Board in                      
             this appeal.                                                                                       
                          47. The Examiner has rejected reissue application claims 1-19                         
             under 35 U.S.C. § 251 maintaining that the reissue declaration is defective.                       
                          48. The Examiner has rejected reissue application claims 2-19                         
             under 35 U.S.C. § 251 maintaining that the claims seek to "recapture" subject                      
                                                     - 13 -                                                     




Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007