Ex Parte GEDNEY et al - Page 7



              Appeal 2006-1454                                                                                         
              Application 09/004,524                                                                                   
              Patent 5,483,421                                                                                         

                     13. Referring to Figure 1, a somewhat diagrammatic or schematic                                   
              representation of a ceramic chip carrier 10 mounted on a glass filled epoxy organic                      
              circuit card 12 by means of solder ball connections 14 is depicted (col. 4, ll. 2-6).                    
                     14. Figure 2 shows the pattern of relative normal displacement between                            
              the card and the chip carrier, which describes the deflection of the card and the                        
              resulting strain in each solder ball under the same 60° C temperature change.                            
                     15. Figure 3 shows the stress in the plane of the module (col. 6, ll. 10-14).                     
                     16. From an examination of Figures 1, 2, and 3, it can be seen that when a                        
              ceramic carrier is attached to an organic circuit board and the temperature of the                       
              structure is changed, a significant amount of stress is introduced into the unit. This                   
              stress is carried by or impressed upon the solder ball connection (col. 6, ll. 15-20).                   
                     17. Applicants state at column 6, lines 20-31, that:                                              
                     [I]n order to resist this stress, i.e. to prevent failure of the unit at the                      
                     solder ball joints 14 or at their connection to the bonding pads on the                           
                     chip or carrier, the solder balls have to be of sufficient size and                               
                     strength and the bonds to the pads sufficiently strong or reinforced to                           
                     withstand the strain without failure. Thus, the solder balls need to act                          
                     not only as an electrical connector for the chip carrier and circuit                              
                     board in the relaxed or unstrained condition, they must also act as                               
                     mechanical structural elements that are "plastic" in nature to prevent                            
                     the induced differential expansion movement of the card and the chip                              
                     carrier transmitting sufficient stress to cause failure of the structure.                         


                                                         - 7 -                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013