Ex parte ROBERT E. STEELE, et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-0942                                                          
          Application 07/877,772                                                      


          are individually wrapped about the pipe, rather than the                    
          continuous wrapping required by the appellants’ claim 1 and                 
          disclosed in Lindsey and Koopman.  In fact, it is the objective             
          of the Tailor invention to improve upon the type of pipe covering           
          in which                                                                    



          individual sheets are used by eliminating the weakness in the               
          joining of the length-wise seams (column 1, line 38 et seq.),               
          which are not present in a continuously wrapped system.                     
          Moreover, there is no teaching in Tailor of stressing the                   
          individual sheets as they are wrapped around the pipe; each sheet           
          is stretched longitudinally to make it heat unstable (column 2,             
          line 5 et seq.), which is necessary since the tightness about the           
          pipe is achieved by heat-shrinking the unstable sheet as the                
          final step of the process (column 2, lines 22 and 23).                      
               Lindsey discloses a pipe wrapped with a continuous sheet,              
          which is placed under tension during application.  No adhesive is           
          utilized, nor is there any additional treatment of the sheet                
          subsequent to the mechanical act of wrapping.  After                        
          acknowledging that a certain amount of tension must be applied as           
          the continuous sheet is wrapped, Lindsey goes on to state that              

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007