Ex Parte BUTLER et al - Page 3



  Appeal No. 94-4210                                                                  
  Application 07/932,415                                                              
               10. A system for the selective reduction of phenylacetylene            
               to styrene in a styrene stream contaminated with                       
               phenylacetylene, said system comprising:                               
                    a single reactor vessel having a flow inlet at one end            
                         and a flow outlet at the other end;                          
                    a first reduction catalyst bed in said reactor vessel             
                    near the flow inlet;                                              
                    a hydrogen injector upstream of said first catalyst bed           
                         arranged to inject hydrogen into said styrene                
                    stream;                                                           
                    a second reduction catalyst bed in said reactor vessel            
                         downstream from said first catalyst bed and near             
                    said flow outlet; and                                             
                    a second hydrogen injector in said reactor vessel                 
                    between said two catalyst beds.                                   
               12. A system for the reduction of phenylacetylene in                   
               styrene, said system comprising:                                       
                    a first reactor vessel having a flow inlet, a flow                
                    outlet, and a reduction catalyst bed therein;                     
                    a second reactor vessel having a flow inlet                       
               communicating with the flow outlet of said first                       
               vessel, and further having a reduction catalyst                        
               bed therein;                                                           
                    a first hydrogen injector for injecting hydrogen into             
                    said first reactor vessel upstream of said                        
               catalyst bed therein; and                                              
                    a second hydrogen injector for injecting hydrogen into            
                         said second reactor vessel upstream of said                  
               catalyst bed therein.                                                  
                                     Discussion                                       
               While the examiner has rejected Claims 10 and 13 under                 
          35 U.S.C. ~ 112, second paragraph, the examiner does not explain            
          why persons having ordinary skill in the art would have had                 
                                        - 3 -                                         




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007