Appeal No. 95-4530 Application 08/077,993 the order of the elements are opposed to that from said oscillation device; a silence distinction circuit to compare the signal from the lines with the pulse voltage signals from said oscillation device to thereby issue a discrimination as there is no signal when it does not have a confirmation that the pulse signals originates from said oscillation device; and a voltage value measurement circuit adapted to confirm voltage values at end portions connected to the two lines and an electric power line with predetermined values. 21. A system for determining an electric wiring state in first and second conductors having first and second source portions and end portions, the first and second source portions being short-circuited to ground potential, comprising: an oscillator connected to one of the first and second conductors, generating a pulse signal conducted by the one of the first and second conductors in first and second directions as first and second pulse signals; a voltage measure circuit connected to said first and second conductors, detecting the first and second pulse signals at the first and second end portions of the first and second conductors, respectively; and means for discriminating the electric wiring state between the first and second source portions and the first and second end portions by comparing a difference in polarity between the first and second pulse signals and the pulse signal. The reference relied upon by the examiner as evidence of obviousness is: Metcalf et al. 4,445,085 April 24, 1984 The appealed claims stand rejected as follows: 3Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007