Appeal No. 96-1021 Application 08/143,512 apparatus comprising: a keyboard for inputting the number of prints to be made of particular ones of the image frames and a criterion representing a characteristic of the image within an image frame that is to be used to identify the particular image frame; a film scanner for scanning the images within each image frame and generating signals representing the images scanned; a computer programmed to analyze the scanned images and the particular image frames based on the criterion; and a printer for printing the particular images according to the number inputted having those characteristics of the particular image frames wherein the computer is programmed to analyze the pre-scan data to identify indoor versus outdoor scenes by comparing the peripheral and central densities of an image. The examiner’s Answer cites the following prior art: Terashita 5,023,656 Jun. 11, 1991 Cosgrove 5,157,482 Oct. 20, 1992 Shimizu 5,159,444 Oct. 27, 1992 Hutcheson et al. 5,161,204 Nov. 3, 1992 (Hutcheson ‘204) Hutcheson et al. 5,274,714 Dec. 28, 1993 (Hutcheson ‘714) OPINION Hutcheson in view of Terashita Claims 45, 49, 53, 57, 61, 69, 73, and 77 stand rejected 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007