Ex parte CAL YUDIN - Page 2




          Appeal No. 96-3064                                                           
          Application 08/089,512                                                       

          displaying and simulating the use of transparent liquid                      
          windshield treatment.  The treatment is marketed in a clear                  
          bottle with labels affixed to the front and back thereof.  The               
          exterior-facing portion of front label has a cut-out portion                 
          through which the interior-facing side of the rear label can be              
          seen through the bottle.  To generate the simulation, the                    
          potential customer shakes the bottle, whereby bubbles form on the            
          interior surface of the bottle wall and rise to the top of the               
          bottle.  The rising bubbles simulate beads of water climbing up              
          the automobile windshield.                                                   
                    Claim 11 reproduced below is further illustrative  of              
          the claimed subject matter.                                                  
                    11.  A method of simulating the beading and sheeting               
          action on a windshield of a liquid windshield treatment product,             
          said method comprising the steps of placing the product in a                 
          substantially clear bottle having interior surfaces, applying a              
          front label to the bottle with the front label being formed with             
          a cut-out portion revealing product within the bottle, applying a            
          back label to the bottle in a location to be viewed through the              
          cut-out portion of the front label with the back label having a              
          graphic indicia printed thereon, shaking the bottle to cause                 
          small bubbles to form in the liquid product and migrate to the               
          interior surfaces of the bottle, and placing the shaken bottle in            
          an upright orientation to cause the bubbles to rise up the                   
          interior surfaces of the bottle and past the cut-out portion                 
          formed in the front label thereby simulating through the cut-out             
          portion the beading and sheeting action of the product when                  
          applied to an actual windshield.                                             
                    The reference of record relied upon by the examiner as             
          evidence of obviousness is:                                                  

                                         -2-                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007