Appeal No. 96-3238 Application No. 08/137,590 viewing habits. A remote monitoring unit 19 (Fig. 1) associated with program selector unit 1 for a television receiver accumulates data representing television usage and attempts to transmit this data to central office computer 14 over a telephone line 13 during a time interval determined by software stored in the remote monitoring unit (col. 3, lines 16-22). If the line is busy, the remote monitoring unit attempts to redial a random interval later (col. 3, lines 63-65). No means is disclosed for identifying a failed terminal. Takayama discloses three embodiments of data transmission control circuits which avoid the effects of distortion and noise. The examiner's description of this reference as teaching "terminating a transmission channel upon detecting the absence of a signal" (final Office action at 3) appears to be a reference to the third embodiment (Figs. 4-6), which activates data processing circuit 43 only if a first synchronizing signal is followed within a predetermined time interval by another synchronizing signal (col. 6, lines 16-40). Regarding motivation, the examiner contends that "the use of time-out counters are [sic] well-known" and "one would have a desire to terminate a connection as soon as a device fails to respond within a given time period" (final Office action at 3). - 5 -Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007