Ex parte THOMAS G. FELDPAUSCH et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-4240                                                          
          Application 08/294,074                                                      


          independent claims 1 and 28.  Even if we were to agree with the             
          examiner’s first contention, we cannot agree with the second                
          contention.                                                                 
               With specific regard to Polhamus the examiner states that:             
                    Polhamus shows panel 18 within [a] channel of                     
               utility post 12.  Compressible connectors such as at                   
               27, 39 or 34, are utilized to hold the panel in place.                 
               [Answer, page 4.]                                                      

          There is, however, absolutely nothing in Polhamus to suggest that           
          the members 27, 39 and 34 are “compressible” connectors which               
          would allow the panel 18 to be “laterally movable” to such an               
          extent so as to permit the panel to be manually mounted in and              
          removed from the support channels of two posts.                             
               In the embodiment of Fig. 1 of Polhamus the panel 18 is held           
          between a flange 36 on each of the posts 12 and a retainer member           
          27 which is slidable horizontally into and out of engagement with           
          a slot 56 in each post, with retainer members in turn being                 
          fastened to each post by a cover 19.  There is absolutely nothing           
          in Polhamus which suggests that the retainer members 27 are                 
          “compressible” as the examiner contends, much less being                    






                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007