Ex parte TAKIZAWA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-3091                                                          
          Application 08/093,311                                                      

          which reasonably would have suggested that the selection of                 
          the number of bits in the error-correction-code is made based               
          on the track address of the data sector to be written in.                   
          Indeed, if anything, McCullough appears to suggest the                      
          contrary, that the same length error-correction-code is always              
          used regardless of the track address.  In that connection,                  
          note the following text in column 19, lines 19-23,                          
          of McCullough:                                                              
                    In the present embodiment only RLL (2,7)                          
                    encoding is utilized and the disk                                 
                    controller 182 is programmed to perform 56-                       
                    bit ECC                                                           
                    [error correction code] on the data field                         
                    and 16-bit CRC on the sector identification                       
                    but could be programmed to perform                                
                    otherwise if desired.                                             
                    The examiner has pointed to nothing to indicate that              
          the programming as described in the above-quoted text is on a               
          track by track basis.  The more plausible reading of                        
          McCullough                                                                  
          is that the length of the code is uniform for all data sectors              
          in all tracks, even though it can be either 56 bits or 32 bits              
          long.                                                                       


                    Neither Yoshimura nor McCullough discloses or                     
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007