Ex parte MAKI et al. - Page 7




                 Appeal No. 95-3124                                                                                                                     
                 Application No. 08/125,311                                                                                                             


                          Figure 1B of Sidman discloses a servo head 27 and a data                                                                      
                 head 26 with a disk 16 located therebetween.  Although Sidman                                                                          
                 discloses “a head selection and amplifying unit 32 for                                                                                 
                 supplying a head selection signal to the drive control unit                                                                            
                 10,” and “a circuit 34 for providing an automatic gain control                                                                         
                 signal for the unit 32,” he “fails to specifically disclose                                                                            
                 the claimed first data head which is collaterally paired with                                                                          
                 the servo heads, the step of supplying a variable write                                                                                
                 current to one of the data write head and thus drives the head                                                                         
                 at the aforementioned current value” (paper number 8, page 3).                                                                         
                          The examiner relies on Nguyen to show that “the use of a                                                                      
                 VGA amplifier is notoriously well known” (paper number 8, page                                                                         
                 4).                                                                                                                                    
                          Weispfenning ‘439 discloses (Figure 1) a data transducer                                                                      
                 18 and a servo transducer 14 supported on the same actuator                                                                            
                 arm between two disks.  According to the examiner, “the                                                                                
                 primary source of undesired electromagnetic radiation  to the                                  3                                       

                          3Appellants’ acknowledged prior art (Figure 1B) discloses                                                                     
                 a data head and a servo head collaterally paired and supported                                                                         
                 by the same actuator arm between two disks.  With such closely                                                                         
                 spaced heads, electromagnetic noise leakage from the data head                                                                         
                 to the servo head will occur during data writing by the data                                                                           
                 head.  Appellants have likewise acknowledged this problem                                                                              
                                                                           7                                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007