Ex parte JOHNSON et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 95-3270                                                          
          Application 08/080,689                                                      



          (Figure 1) is used to select a particular character and                     
          thereby establish which daisy wheel printing unit 27 and print              
          element 84 will be activated to print the selected character.               
          As an alternative, the patentee (column 10, lines 50 through 53,            
          and column 11, lines 33 through 40) contemplates generating a               
          digital address for retrieving a prerecorded storage character to           
          be printed.                                                                 


                    The Toyoda patent teaches a photoelectric reader which            
          enables one to record only a selected portion of an original,               
          such as a portion of a page document.  This is accomplished by a            
          reader part R moving on an original 8 to read or scan selected              
          image data and transform same into electric signals, which                  
          signals are used for effecting the recording of the images on               
          paper 7 in a printer part P (Figure 1).                                     


                    While, as evidenced by the Toyoda teaching,                       
          photoelectric readers are certainly known, it is readily apparent           
          to us that one having ordinary skill in the art, absent                     
          appellants’ own explicit teaching, would not have been motivated,           
          from a combined consideration of the respective teachings of                
          Johnson and Toyoda alone, to alter the teaching of Johnson as               
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007