Ex parte INUZUKA et al. - Page 3




          Appeal No. 95-3408                                                          
          Application 08/003,448                                                      


                                       OPINION                                        
               We reverse this rejection.                                             
               The above noted language reflects the disclosed feature that           
          the data select signal 19 alternates between high and low                   
          positions each half of the horizontal period in accordance with             
          the pulse clock 10 having a frequency twice that of the line                
          clock 9 wherein N = 2 in accordance with the operation of circuit           
          figure 9.  Stated differently, the processing provided for the              
          multi-level tone display data common to claims 19 and 20 is that            
          it is divided into at least two portions and all of the divided             
          data are provided in one horizontal period of one frame to the              
          liquid crystal display panel of claim 19 or the multi-level tone            
          display means at the end of claim 21 on appeal.                             
               On the other hand, the examiner’s position at the bottom of            
          page 3 of the answer indicates that Barbier requires two complete           
          scans of the matrix display to completely apply the two kinds of            
          multi-level display data to the display device in this reference.           
          We are in agreement with appellants’ characterization at page 4             
          of the reply brief that Barbier’s system provides the divided               
          data  to a matrix panel in alternate frames.  The abstract                  
          indicates that the memory planes in Fig. 2 are read sequentially.           



                                          3                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007