Ex parte COOMBS et al. - Page 13




          Appeal No. 95-4152                                                          
          Application 08/042,044                                                      

          the wearer of the head gear 102" (Br19) and, as shown in                    
          figure 11, "is not mounted underneath the brim of the Hanson                
          helmet 40" (Br20).  Appellants do not argue that figures 10                 
          and 11 do not show a camera.  Appellants do address figure 9,               
          which shows equipment 90 which could be an infrared video                   
          camera, in their arguments.  We find that the night vision                  
          equipment 90 in figure 9 is intended to be mounted in the same              
          relative position to the user's eye and the helmet as the                   
          display 104 in figure 11.  The display 104 is "generally                    
          underneath said brim" because it is located mostly underneath               
          the brim of the helmet 40.  Also, the face frame "includes an               
          outwardly extending shell 96 which houses the video display 88              
          and night vision equipment 90" (col. 8, lines 2-4) and the                  
          display 88 and equipment 90 "are thereby protected" (col. 8,                
          lines 6-7).  The outwardly extending shell of the face frame                
          forms an extension of the helmet brim.  In addition, as                     
          discussed supra, it would have been a matter of common sense                
          to one skilled in the art to locate a camera under the helmet               
          brim where there is known to exist an envelope of reduced                   
          heat.                                                                       
               For these reasons, the rejection of claim 1 is sustained.              

                                       - 13 -                                         





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007