Ex parte ZAGUROLI et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-1086                                                          
          Application 08/326,604                                                      



          brief that claim 1 sets forth "separate shafts mounted on a                 
          support member to be held spaced apart but parallel . . . ."                
          However, appellants have not then pointed out or specified                  
          supposed errors in the examiner's rejection with regard to                  
          claim 1, or provided an explanation of how limitations in                   
          claim 1 would render the claimed subject matter therein                     
          unobvious over the applied prior art reference to Gallone.                  
          The examiner has taken the position that the embodiment of the              
          guide (13) in Figure 5 of Gallone includes separate upper and               
          lower guide bars defined respectively by the upper enlarged                 
          portion of the guide (13) and the lower enlarged portion of                 
          the guide (13) on which the roller sets (20) ride.  These                   
          "guide bars" are mounted on and supported by the intermediate               
          portion of the guide (13) and are held spaced apart                         
          but extending parallel to each other.  A holder member defined              
          by elements (14, 15, 14) in Figure 5 of Gallone carries the                 
          upper and lower sets of rollers mounted thereon so that they                
          are spaced apart to receive the upper and lower guide bars.                 





                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007