Ex parte BENEDICT - Page 9




          Appeal No. 97-2904                                                          
          Application 08/565,457                                                      


          operates valve 116 to connect chamber 82 to pump 90 to thereby              
          establish a high vacuum level in chamber 82 for lifting the                 
          sheet from a platen 12 and for securely retaining it against                
          belts 70 and 72. In the second mode of operation, which occurs              
          as the sheet approaches the registration member 34, controller              
          136 operates valve 136 in the reverse fashion to disconnect                 
          chamber 82 from pump 90 and to restore atmospheric pressure to              
          chamber 82. The lower vacuum level in chamber 84 is sufficient              
          to retain the sheet against belts 70 and 72 to allow the sheet              
          to strike registration member 34 without damaging the sheet.                


                 Appellant argues that Dragstedt is deficient for the                 
          following reasons:                                                          


                    This patent does not teach that the sheet                         
                    slips on the belt when it engages the                             
                    registration member. This patent also does                        
                    not teach means for sensing the sheet                             
                    advancing on the transport and a controller                       
                    responsive to the sensing means for                               
                    switching the transport between modes of                          
                    operation. Furthermore, there is no                               
                    teaching contained in this patent that the                        
                    frictional force between the sheet and the                        
                    transport is reduced to permit relative                           
                    movement between the sheet and the                                
                    transport. At most, this reference teaches                        
                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007