WANG V. TUCHOLSKI - Page 105




          Interference No. 103,036                                                    


                    visible change when the temperature exceeds a                     
                    predetermined value.  Alteratively, the                           
                    device can be fabricated without the                              
                    pyrotechnic chemical, relying on the color-                       
                    indicating, heat-sensitive material alone to                      
                    indicate whether the battery has a                                
                    predetermined minimal voltage output.  If the                     
                    color indicating, heat-sensitive material                         
                    undergoes a non-permanent color change when                       
                    exposed to a predetermined temperature, then                      
                    the battery-strength indicator device of FIG.                     
                    10D can be used repeatedly to determine if                        
                    the output voltage of the battery meets a                         
                    predetermined voltage level.  [Emphasis                           
                    added.]                                                           
          The Party Cataldi et al.'s Position                                         
                    The party Cataldi et al. relies upon Dr. Feder's                  
          testimony in order to show that the foregoing specification does            
          not contain a written description for the limitation, "sufficient           
          means under one of its [the conductive layer's] surfaces to                 
          permit the heat generated" by the conductive layer to change the            
          color of the temperature sensitive color indicator, of reissue              
          claims 16 to 23.                                                            
                    Dr. Feder testified (1) that these claims are directed            
          to the indicator device 10D shown in Burroughs et al.'s Figure 10           
          [CR 60], (2) that the device does not disclose sufficient means             
          under one of the conductive layer's surfaces to permit the heat             
          generated by the conductive layer to change the color of the                
          temperature sensitive color indicator and to indicate voltage [CR           
          60], (3) that the specification is completely silent regarding              
          the effects of thermal conduction of heat from the indicator                
                                        -28-                                          



Page:  Previous  98  99  100  101  102  103  104  105  106  107  108  109  110  111  112  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007