Ex parte BARNS-SLAVIN et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-4383                                                          
          Application 08/110,456                                                      


                    It is of course apparent that other techniques may                
               be employed for entering discount information.  The                    
               responses to the prompts are preferably simple in form,                
               such as Y(es) or N(o) to questions that have two choices,              
               or numeric entries based upon items listed in the various              
               menus, in accordance with conventional practice.                       
                    The system of the invention stores data                           
               corresponding to previous transactions with each carrier               
               and/or class, so that it can determine the cost of the                 
               current shipment on the basis of any discounts that are                
               applicable.  The discounts are of course not applied to                
               the other carriers/classes, unless they have been so                   
               programmed.                                                            
                    In a further aspect of the invention, the system may              
               print reports to enable the user to determine how much                 
               use had been made of the various discounts, thereby                    
               enabling the user to take as much advantage of the                     
               discounts as possible. For example, the menu 501a may                  
               enable the selection of a subroutine 512 for printing                  
               such reports.  [Col. 6, lines 25-61.]                                  
               Although Barns-Slavin states that "the computer comprises              
          means responsive to operation of the selection keys for                     
          applying discounts stored in the second memory means to any                 
          carrier and/or class to which they are applicable "(col. 1,                 
          line 68 to col. 2, line 3), it does not provide any details                 
          about how this is accomplished.                                             
               Barns-Slavin does not mention a discount for sending a                 
          group of parcels to the same consignee or assigning the                     
          parcels in such a group with the same identification number                 
          and different suffixes, as required by claim 1.  Although                   

                                        - 7 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007