Ex parte LEW - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1996-0249                                       Page 6           
          Application No. 08/076,709                                                  

                    The condiment-laden core is afforded a measure of:                
               protection (by the dry coating thereon) against                        
               deterioration caused by exposure to the atmosphere;                    
               control for release of the condiment into a foodstuff or               
               the like in which it is compounded, the surface coating                
               dissolving to release the condiment at a desired, rather               
               than at an accidental juncture; prevention of undesired                
               interaction between condiment and its surrounding                      
               materials in a food, drug, or cosmetic; and prevention of              
               the condiment coloring and/or flavoring ingredient to                  
               bleach, run, dilute or evaporate....                                   
                    The amount of such protection is dependent upon                   
               the specific-coating material chosen, the coating                      
               thickness, and the completeness of the coating on                      
               the condiment core.                                                    
               In light of the above and a fair reading of the full                   
          disclosure of Johnson, it is our view that Johnson prefers the              
          use of a meltable lipoidal material in the core (columns 3 and              
          4, and the Example at columns 7 and 8) and teaches selecting                
          the coating (shell) material from among those listed at                     
          columns 3 and 4, including the edible resins such as                        
          methylcellulose and hydroxypropylmethylcellulose, depending on              
          the surrounding environment and the amount of protection                    
          desired to prevent                                                          
          interaction with surrounding food materials, dilution and                   
          evaporation of the coating.  While Johnson illustrates the use              
          of a shellac resin as the coating in the sole example                       







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007