Ex parte KANE et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-0338                                                          
          Application 08/095,179                                                      


               As a starting point the subject matter of independent                  
          claims 1 and 22 on appeal is derived from a showing in                      
          appellants' Figure 2 within the large dashed block element                  
          which in turn feeds the voice recognizer circuit element 10.                
          In an analogous manner, Kroschel's Figure 1 at the bottom of                
          page 82 of that reference shows conceptually his noise                      
          reduction system feeding a speech recognition system.  The                  
          examiner's reliance upon the specific types of cepstral coding              
          features discussed at column 1 of page 83 relate only to the                
          speech recognition block in Kroschel's Figure 1 at the bottom               
          of page 82 as expressed in the topic heading at the top of                  
          column 1 at page 83.                                                        
               On the other hand, the specific noise reduction                        
          techniques taught in this reference beginning at the bottom of              
          column 1 at page 84 of this reference conceptually relate to                
          the noise reduction block in Figure 1 at the bottom of page 82              
          of this reference.  Column 2 of page 84 relates to a specific               
          approach, apparently the only approach actually taught in                   
          Kroschel, to reducing noise within an incoming signal which                 
          approach is based upon the average of the noise power spectrum              
          calculated by FFT in speech pauses according to a particular                
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007