Ex parte PALMITER et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-0423                                                          
          Application 08/126,439                                                      


          declination adjustments in the antenna structure in Gorton. We              
          do, however, recognize that Gorton does explicitly teach a                  
          periodic oscillatory motion of the antenna to follow a                      
          satellite on a sidereal day basis only for the declination                  
          adjustability of his antenna in this reference.  To the                     
          extent, for example, the abstract of Gorton expresses that the              
          antenna may automatically adjust the declination angle of the               
          antenna as a function of time, it would necessarily do it on a              
          periodic oscillatory basis for a given sidereal day in an                   
          effort to maximize the signal strength received in the antenna              
          from the satellite.  This aspect is brought out among the                   
          various flow chart figures and the written description of                   
          Gorton relating to the computerized control of the motor                    
          arrangement 80 by the computer 20 in Figure 1.                              
               We make reference on our own to the initializing flow                  
          chart Figure 4 of Gorton and its flow chart steps 112 through               
          116 as well as column 7, lines 29 through 36.  It appears that              
          the reference as a whole teaches that the so-called North-                  
          South movability of the antenna corresponds to declination                  
          angle changes, whereas the discussion at this location appears              


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007