Ex parte CHIGASAKI - Page 7




          Appeal No. 96-0528                                                          
          Application No. 08/151,463                                                  


          in the sense of fastening the elevator chassis to the main                  
          chassis wherein the elevator chassis cannot move until                      
          unfastened (as by movement of the pull-out lever 44).                       
               Moreover, as the “elevation drive mechanism” and the                   
          “locking mechanism” are claimed as two separate elements, we                
          view these elements as being separate and distinct, especially              
          in view of appellant’s written intent that they be construed                
          as separate and distinct elements [bottom of page 10 to the                 
          top of page 11 of the brief].  In Miyoshi, if one regards the               
          screws 121 and its attendant elements, including the lift                   
          drive motor 125, as the “locking mechanism,” then the “locking              
          mechanism” is not separate and distinct from the “elevation                 
          drive mechanism,” 125 in Miyoshi.                                           
               Further, instant claim 1 does not merely call for the                  
          elevator chassis to be locked to the main chassis, but,                     
          rather, that they be locked together “in a ganged relation                  
          with the disc pull-out operation of the disc pull-out                       
          mechanism...”  In Miyoshi, any such disc pull-out mechanism                 
          would be the tray hook 112 but this hook is clearly not “in a               
          ganged relation” with the elevator and main chassis.  At page               
          7 of the brief, appellant contends that a “ganged relation,”                
                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007