Ex parte BENKUAL et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1229                                                          
          Application 08/104,819                                                      

               conversation; and the use of each participant’s CCB                    
               with a pointer to a head message queue (e.g., fig.                     
               7E and column 24).                                                     
               But the applicants are correct that in Pagé the CCB                    
          chains and the corresponding message queues are all within the              
          broker processing node.  There is no indication that any                    
          message queue or CCB chain referred to by the examiner is                   
          located within a client or server node.  The examiner has made              
          no reasonable demonstration as to why a conversation control                
          block CCB containing the head pointer to a message queue and                
          its corresponding message queue are located in different data               
          processing nodes as is required by applicants’ claim 6.  The                
          fact that a client’s CCB contains a partner CCB pointer                     
          leading to the CCB for the server on the other side of the                  
          broker which is communicating with the client does not mean                 
          the client’s CCB is located in the client node and the                      
          server’s CCB is located in the server node.  It is apparent                 
          that the CCB’s and message queues are tools used by the                     
          interconnecting broker and thus are contained within the                    
          broker data processing node.  See Pagé column 19, line 58, to               
          column 20, line 2, and column 24, lines 22-24.  We agree with               
          the following statement of the applicants (Reply at 2):                     

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007