Ex parte YIP et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1996-1566                                                        
          Application No. 08/095,369                                                  


               The examiner relies upon a combination of three                        
          references to disclose the claimed subject matter.  It is the               
          examiner’s position that one skilled in the art would have                  
          found it obvious to add an organometallic catalyst taught in                
          Sumida to the composition of Endo as an adhesion promoter for               
          a hydroxy terminated polydiorganosiloxane.  See Answer, page                
          5.  We disagree.                                                            
               Endo discloses a primer composition on a substrate                     
          material.  See column 1, lines 6 - 8.  The primer includes an               
          epoxy resin, an amino group containing silane, an additional                
          organic silicon containing compound, a silane containing a                  
          mercapto group and an organic solvent.  See Endo, column 1,                 
          line 55 through column 2, 12.  The composition is spread as a               
          primer on base materials such as glass, aluminum, mortar and                
          polyester.  Thereafter an aminoxy-type silicone sealant is                  
          applied to the primer.  See Example 1.                                      
          We find that Endo discloses each of the components (A), (B)                 
          and (D) required by the claimed subject matter.  There is no                
          disclosure of component (C), an organometallic compound.                    
               Sumida likewise discloses a primer composition spread on               
          a substrate as a primer for silicon rubber or an elastomeric                
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007