Ex parte NEMOTO et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 96-1893                                                          
          Application 08/073,416                                                      



          capstan shaft through the magnetic tape, i.e., to restrain the              
          change in positional relationship caused by a force of the                  
          pinch roller pressing the magnetic tape against the capstan                 
          more than                                                                   
          a predetermined degree."  This limitation is recited in claim               
          12 (last paragraph) as "wherein the positioning means is                    
          connected to both the main chassis and the slide chassis to                 
          restrain the change in positional relationship between the                  
          main chassis and the slide chassis in the at least one                      
          direction when a force of the pinch roller pressing the                     
          magnetic tape against the capstan is more than a predetermined              
          degree" (emphasis added).  In contrast, Appellants argue,                   
          Tsuchida teaches engagement through the positioning means                   
          (Figure 4, element 121 with 122) is "only obtained at the end               
          of the feed path regardless of whether or not the magnetic                  
          tape is pressed against the capstan shaft by the pinch                      
          roller." (Brief at page 9).                                                 
               The Examiner maintains "that Tsuchida et al clearly                    
          shows in Figure 4 the positioning means is connected to both                
          of the main chassis and the slide chassis to restrain the                   

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007