Ex parte HASENBEIN et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1996-3808                                        Page 5           
          Application No. 08/213,832                                                   


               Our construction of the subject matter as defined by                    
          appellants’ claims 3 is that the phrase “metering further                    
          initiator” does not preclude the presence of additional                      
          components such as ethylene, alkenoic acid or esters thereof in              
          addition to the initiator.  Accordingly, a disclosure by                     
          Metzger of the addition of initiator, ethylene and other                     
          monomers to a second zone is sufficient to satisfy the                       
          requirements of appellants claimed subject matter supra. See                 
          Metzger column 3, lines 38 - 55. Metzger discloses therein that              
          the mainstream of a gaseous mixture of ethylene, C  - C  alkene1  3                      
          carboxylic acid and initiator are fed into the reactor.                      
          Thereafter,                                                                  
               “[T]he mainstream is passed in at the beginning of the                  
               reactor, and the sidestream is fed into the reactor in a                
               conventional manner in the region of the second point, at               
               which the temperature reaches a maximum.”                               

          Based upon the above considerations, we conclude that Metzger                
          discloses metering initiator to the beginning of a second                    
          reaction zone.                                                               
          As to appellants’ requirement in the claimed subject                         
          matter that the initiator is inserted after the temperature had              









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007