Ex parte SOENEN et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1997-0884                                                        
          Application 08/260,148                                                      

          transmitter-specific and cannot be altered, and an alterable                
          portion, CWA , etc., which is alterable in a known manner in                
                      1                                                               
          accordance with a desired algorithm (col. 3, line 68, to                    
          col. 4, line 7).  The receiver can be placed in a "learning                 
          phase" where the key code word of the receiver is reprogrammed              
          by the next code word transmitted to the receiver from an                   
          arbitrary transmitter (col. 1, lines 47-57).  Unauthorized use              
          of the remote control system with a lost transmitter can be                 
          prevented by automatically invalidating, i.e, blocking or                   
          erasing, the basic code word portion (col. 3, lines 20-27).                 
               As to the step of "setting a flag in a memory of an                    
          integrated circuit upon the first time the integrated circuit               
          is placed in a learn mode while configured as a receiver," the              
          closest reasoning we find is the Examiner's statement for the               
          first time in the Examiner's Answer that "Lindmayer, col. 3,                
          line 24 implies that an equivalent to a flag must be set since              
          the erasing of a code is accomplished in the system dependant               
          [sic] upon if the code has been used (received) at least once,              
          here the flag must have been set in the system which was                    
          acting in a receiving mode" (EA5).  This is a broad, but fair               
          reading of Lindmayer.  Whatever hardware or software keeps                  

                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007