Ex parte CASAGRANDE et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-0906                                                         
          Application 08/292,666                                                       

               Darlow discloses a metal handle tie bar for circuit                     
          breaker handles.  The handle tie bar has a channel shaped                    
          cross section comprised of bottom 16 and opposing sides 18 and               
          20.  The sides 18 and 20 are formed with spurs 22 which dig                  
          into the plastic handles of the circuit breaker and resist                   
          removal of the tie bar from the handles.  The bottom of the                  
          channel has windows 24 to show the amperage markings on the                  
          end of the handles.  We disagree with Appellants' finding that               
          Darlow has "apertures for receiving the circuit breaker                      
          handles" (Br7).  The windows 24 show the amperage markings,                  
          but it appears that the ends of the handles abut the bottom 16               
          on the edges of the windows because figure 3 shows that the                  
          width of the windows is less than the width of the handles and               
          because the edge of the sidewall is visible along the lower                  
          edge of the window.  The Examiner relies on Darlow only for                  
          its teaching of the placement of spurs 22.                                   
               Kakisako discloses a handle tie which fits over the end                 
          of the circuit breaker handles and having a groove 8b and                    
          protrusions 9 which engage a connecting pin 5 which extends                  
          through holes in the handles.  The handle tie has compartments               



                                        - 4 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007