Ex parte MASAND - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1997-0920                                                         
          Application 08/274,123                                                       

          match token sorter for sorting generated match tokens" (EA5)                 
          as stated by the Examiner.  Dickinson does not sort match                    
          tokens "according to the document identifier information and                 
          the text symbol sequence information associated therewith,"                  
          i.e., according to the key value of the location of the query                
          in the document text base by document number and position.                   
          Thus, we find that Dickinson does not disclose the claimed                   
          "match token sorter for sorting match tokens generated by said               
          match token generator according to the document identifier                   
          information and the text symbol sequence information                         
          associated therewith."                                                       
               Lastly, the Examiner finds the "query processor" to                     
          correspond to the processing textual identifier blocks that                  
          determine the sets of equivalent words in the text that                      
          satisfy the query, referring to abstract, lines 1-13, and                    
          column 9, lines 50-68 (FR2) and to column 29, lines 30-46 (in                
          claim 1 of Dickinson) (EA6).  The Examiner fails to address                  
          the following underlined claim language "query processor for                 
          identifying, using the query symbol sequence information                     
          associated with the match tokens as sorted by the match token                
          sorter, sequences of match tokens relating to a query which                  

                                        - 9 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007