Ex parte OTA et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 97-1198                                                          
          Application No. 08/245,954                                                  


          that stops the drive circuit in response to disk ejection, a                
          signal processor 5 that processes the image information                     
          reproduced from the disk, and a signal processor 6 that                     
          processes the audio information reproduced from the disk.                   
               The examiner acknowledges (Answer, page 4) that Shimada                
          "does not specifically disclose[s] reset means or a reset                   
          circuit for initializing the signal processing means . . . in               
          response to the disc ejecting means or disc ejector ejecting                
          the disc."                                                                  
               The admitted prior art discloses (specification, page 2)               
          that:                                                                       
                    [W]hen the CD-I disc is removed during the                        
               reproducing process, the last displayed image                          
               remains and the sound is jammed.  A reset switch is                    
               typically used to manually reset the CD-I player to                    
               the initial state so that the processing steps can                     
               be again sequentially executed according to the                        
               contents of the new CD-I disc.                                         
               The examiner is of the opinion (Answer, page 5) that                   
          "[i]t would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the               
          art at the time of the invention to provide Shimada et al.’s                
          system with the reset switch in a manner as taught in the                   
          admitted prior art."                                                        


                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007