Ex parte HARTMAN - Page 4




          Appeal No. 97-4081                                                          
          Application 08/379,793                                                      



          by an electric motor or hydraulic jacks controlled by a pump.               
          See column 5, lines 24 through 33.  In the instance where the               
          cylinders are hydraulic, the cylinders would be composed of a               
          piston slidably mounted therein with one part of the cylinder               
          or piston contacting the contact surface via the agency of                  
          wheel 25.  It must be emphasized that in the hydraulic embodi-              
          ment, the cylinders of the reference would be "in fluid commu-              
          nication"  with the pump "to allow the contact surfaces to                  
          extend or retract                                                           
          relative to the respective supports."  While claim 1 and the                
          claims dependent thereon do not require the cylinders to be in              


          fluid communication with one another or be interconnected by                
          a conduit, they do require that the cylinders extend or                     
          retract equally and oppositely of each other.  It is clear                  
          that the cylinders of Chatenay épouse Compagnone when in fluid              
          communi- cation with the pump do not provide for this opposite              
          and equal movement.  Therefore, it can be seen that the                     
          Chatenay épouse Compagnone reference fails to disclose each                 
          and every element   of claims 1 through 4.                                  

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007