Ex parte EARLE et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 98-1354                                                          
          Application 08/218,507                                                      


          housing, a saw blade rotatably supported on the carriage, a                 
          motor mounted on the carriage for rotating the saw blade, a                 
          battery supported by the housing for supplying power to the                 
          motor, gripping members carried on the housing and movable                  
          between an open position and a closed position for firming                  
          gripping an object to be cut, means for actuating the gripping              
          members to closed positions where they firmly grip the object               
          to be cut, and a manually operable actuator carried by the                  
          housing and operatively connected with the carriage for moving              
          the carriage from a retracted inoperative position to a                     
          advanced operative position.                                                


               We turn now to the evidence of obviousness.                            


               The patent to Hanaway teaches a manually-held power-                   
          driven pipe cutter (Figure 1) which is indicated to be readily              
          portable (column 2, lines 5,6). A secondary frame 19, slidably              
          mounted on a main frame 11, is moved by rotation of a clamping              
          screw 34 threadedly received in the main frame. A drive motor               
          57, slidably received in the main frame and the secondary                   
          frame, includes an                                                          
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007