Ex parte BODINE et al. - Page 5



          Appeal No. 98-1449                                         Page 5           
          Application No. 08/297,122                                                  


               [i]t is well known in any facet of construction that if                
               there are two or more elements which interfere with each               
               other or there is an interference fit that some form of                
               relieving, notching or removal of a portion of one of the              
               elements would be performed. This is a rather typical                  
               procedure and is "obvious" in the true sense of the word.              
               The concept has universal application and is just as                   
               relevant to an apparent unsightly suspended ceiling                    
               system as to a basic framing of a building.  It is                     
               further well known to customize a component to fit into                
               an existing system.  Therefore, if the raised portions of              
               the ceiling grid system cause the ceiling board to lie                 
               unevenly, it would have been obvious to one with ordinary              
               skill in the art to modify the board of Shaub by removing              
               the offending portions thereof, i.e. creating depressions              
               in the corners, to create a tolerance for the raised                   
               portions of the ceiling grid system so that the support                
               edge means of the board may lie flat against the support               
               means of the ceiling grid system around the entire                     
               perimeter, thus presenting a level finished construction               
               by modifying the ceiling board with a method old and well              
               known in the art.                                                      





















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007