Ex parte HANLON - Page 3




          Appeal No. 98-2033                                                          
          Application 08/507,623                                                      


          the "Grouping of Claims" heading, the appellant states that                 
          "Claims 1-10 stand or fall together."  Therefore, and in                    
          accordance with 37 CFR         § 1.192(c)(7), we shall decide               
          the appeal on the basis of representative claim 1, with claims              
          2 through 10 standing or falling therewith.                                 
               Jones discloses a tamper-indicating label 15 comprising,               
          inter alia, label material 11 composed of a foamed, stretched,              
          uniaxially oriented polyolefin film, a pressure-sensitive                   
          adhesive 13 on the bottom surface of the film and ink printing              
          18 (e.g., the word "CUSTOMS") on the upper surface of the                   
          film.  Figures 4 and 5 show the label applied to a container                
          as a closure seal.  Jones explains that                                     
               [t]he foaming and stretching contribute                                
               substantially to the high gloss decorative                             
               appearance of the film material and provide a                          
               telltale indication of tampering if attempted to be                    
               removed.  As the film is weak in the longitudinal                      
               direction it tears easily if attempted to be                           
               removed.  In addition, as the adhesive resists any                     
               attempt to strip the material from the surface of                      
               the article to which it is applied, the material                       
               wrinkles permanently and noticeably upon being                         
               stripped from the surface.  Accordingly, the tape or                   
               label of the invention is particularly useful as a                     
               tamperindicating [sic] device [column 1, lines 30                      
               through 41].                                                           

               At issue in this appeal is whether Jones teaches, or                   
                                          3                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007