Ex parte SHAHID - Page 2




          Appeal No. 98-2261                                                           
          Application 08/314,829                                                       




               The prior art applied by the examiner is:                               
          Craig                 5,013,085                 May   7, 1991                
          Baron                 5,326,152                 Jul.  5, 1994                
          DeMars                5,350,215                 Sep. 27, 1994                
          Sinohuiz              5,356,107                 Oct. 18, 1994                
          (filed Jul. 19, 1993)                                                        
          The admitted prior art in appellant’s Declaration Under Rule                 
          132 filed on August 15, 1996 (APA).                                          
               The appealed claims stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103                
          on the following grounds:                                                    
          (1)  Claims 1 to 5, 14 and 15, unpatentable over DeMars in                   
          view of Craig and Baron;                                                     
          (2)  Claims 7 to 13, 17 and 18, unpatentable over DeMars in                  
          view of Craig, Baron and Sinohuiz;                                           
          (3)  Claims 6 and 16, unpatentable over DeMars in view of                    
          Craig, Baron and APA.3                                                       
          Rejection (1)                                                                
               Appellant argues as to this rejection that the subject                  
          matter recited in claim 1 is patentable over DeMars in view of               
          Craig and Baron because:                                                     



               3This was a new ground of rejection made in the examiner’s answer.      
                                           2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007