Ex parte MAY - Page 11




          Appeal No. 99-0622                                        Page 11           
          Application No. 08/637,717                                                  



          We note that the "connecting means" is recited as part of the               
          safety harness.                                                             


               The examiner has identified the rear or free end (18) as               
          the "relatively weaker juncture," the box stitch (41) or                    
          buckle rod (36) as the "relatively stronger juncture" and the               
          tether strap (42) and strip (40) as at least part of the                    
          "connecting means" (answer, page 5).  Since the "connecting                 
          means" is defined in claim 25 as part of the safety harness,                
          as opposed to additional structure in combination with the                  
          safety harness, the tether strap (42) and strip (40) must be                
          considered part of the harness when reading the claim on the                
          Leach device.  Consequently, the junctures (18) and (41) or                 
          (36) must be viewed, for comparison with the claimed                        
          invention, as being disposed between parts of the harness                   
          (e.g., between waistband 12 and shoulder straps 22,24 and                   
          between strip 40 and tether strap 42 or shoulder straps 22,24,              
          respectively) and not between the support structure and the                 
          harness as required by claim 25.  We find only one juncture                 
          disposed between a support structure and the harness as                     








Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007