Ex parte BOCHET - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-2092                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 08/798,718                                                  


               away from the path of seam 55 and into the outlet                      
               extension 30. Thus, undesired tearing along the path of                
               seam 55 is prevented.                                                  
                    It should be appreciated that the particular                      
               construction of the preferred embodiment protects the tab              
               member 42 from being accidentally ruptured or damaged                  
               during the manufacturing process. More particularly,                   
               during the manufacturing process the two sheets 13 and 15              
               of polyvinyl chloride material are electronically welded               
               together forming the seams 36, 38, 39, 54 and 55 and                   
               resulting in the presence of excess polyvinyl chloride                 
               material extending outwardly from the peripheral seams                 
               36, 38 and 39. This excess material is usually removed by              
               cutting or tearing. By shielding the major portion of the              
               tab member 42 within the confines of the upper portion                 
               59, the tab member 42 is protected against accidental                  
               tearing or damage during removal of this excess material.              


               In our view, claim 42 is anticipated by Salvadori.  In                 
          that regard, claim 42 is readable on Salvadori as follows:                  
          A bag (Salvadori's bag 10) comprising a pair of flexible                    
          tearable walls (Salvadori's sheets 13 and 15) defining between              
          them a central volume (Salvadori's chamber 14) for containing               
          a product, said walls being secured together along and                      
          transversely of an elongated margin of substantial width                    
          extending between an outer edge of said bag and said central                
          volume (Salvadori's seams 36 and 54 secure the sheets 13 and                
          15 together and define therebetween an elongated margin of                  
          substantial width extending between outer seam 36 and the                   







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007