Ex parte KELLNER et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-2761                                                        
          Application No. 08/790,322                                                  


          above-quoted portion of col. 7 of Speller discloses that the                
          second function of controller 1038 is "fault monitoring                     
          wherein controller 1038 detects and records error conditions,               
          classifies them according to user-defined severity levels,                  
          response [sic: responds] to errors by shutting down                         
          malfunctioning equipment, . . ." (lines 51 to 55).  Keeping in              
          mind that fastening machines 16, 18 constitute part of the                  
          equipment cell 10, and that one function of controller 84                   
          (1038) is disclosed as being "for monitoring operation of the               
          machines 16, 18" (col. 7, lines 2 to 5), it is evident that in              
          order for the controller to monitor the operation of the                    
          fastening machines, to record error conditions in those                     
          machines, and to shut them down if they were malfunctioning                 
          (col. 7, line 55), it would be necessary to gather                          
          measurements and data from the fastening machines while they                
          were in operation installing fasteners in the workpiece 44,                 
          46, etc., as recited in step (a) of claim 24, and then to                   
          transmit, i.e., download, such measurements and data to the                 
          controller 1038, as recited in step (b).  Otherwise, the                    
          controller would not be able to operate as disclosed by                     
          Speller, in that it could not monitor the operation of the                  
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007