Ex parte BLALOCK et al. - Page 15




         Appeal No. 2000-0721                                     Page 15          
         Reissue Application No. 08/628,287                                        


         claims 67 specifies in pertinent part the following                       
         limitations: "an electrically conductive layer provided over              
         the dielectric layer, a portion of the surface of the                     
         electrically conductive layer including partial striations."              


              The examiner fails to show that the limitations are                  
         indefinite.  The specification discloses that "a conformal                
         capacitor cell layer 66 of conductive material, such as                   
         conductively doped polysilicon, is conformally deposited atop             
         capacitor dielectric layer 64.  Striations from internal and              
         external surfaces of layer 64 will probably only partially                
         translate to outer surfaces of layer 66 due to the increasing             
         thickness and corresponding smoothing effect imparted                     
         by subsequent layers."  Col. 5, ll. 22-29.  When read in light            
         of the specification, one skilled in the art would understand             
         that the claimed striations on the surface of the electrically            
         conductive layer are partial relative to the claimed                      
         striations of the dielectric layer.  We demand no more.                   
         Therefore, we reverse the rejection of claim 5-83 under 35                
         U.S.C. § 112.                                                             








Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007