Ex parte BOSCH - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2000-1275                                                        
          Application No. 08/839,984                                                  


          repositionable adhesive which coats the back layer.  The                    
          entire manifold is placed in the typewriter which impacts the               
          carbon                                                                      
          paper-like front layer and leaves an indicia on the compressed              
          sleeves.  At any time the front layer can be gently peeled                  
          from the back layer and one or several sleeves removed                      
          therefrom.                                                                  




               According to the examiner, Johnstun is relied upon for                 
          teaching repositionable adhesive on the front side of the                   
          sheet for removably securing another member.  In the                        
          examiners' view, it would have been obvious to modify the                   
          sheet of Williams to have the repositionable adhesive on the                
          front side of the sheet as opposed to on the card of Williams               
          as taught by Johnstun.  We do not agree with the examiner.  In              
          our view, it would not have been obvious to modify Williams in              
          such a manner, because the function of Williams would be                    
          destroyed.  More specifically, if the adhesive in Williams                  
          were not disposed on the sticker or smaller second sheet, then              
          the sticker would not adhere to the telephone.  As Williams                 
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007