Appeal No. 1995-4702
Application 08/071,049
This language corresponds to the showing in Figure 2 of
the data structures of the server extension, as well as the
data structures of the X server, which the extension has
access to. These features are also discussed at page 4 in the
summary of the invention of the specification as filed as well
as the text thereof beginning at page 8.
We agree with the appellants' view that Keefe does not
disclose the claimed extension portion of memory corresponding
to the server portion of memory and the extension routines
that structurally correspond to the server routines to which
the inputs and output protocol requests are directed. The
Keefe system utilizes the monitor control program and its
associated test analysis program in an hierarchical
environment for purposes of performing systems evaluation or
monitoring. Our study of Keefe leads us to agree with the
appellants' views expressed at top of page 9 of the principal
brief on appeal:
"Keefe, however, fails to disclose any of the
structure of the monitor control program, the
associated test analysis program or other elements
of the Keefe system. Accordingly, Keefe does not
disclose any correspondences between the server
extension and server as required by the claimed
5
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007